Jump to content
SportsWrath

Best and worst Giants draft picks of all time.


Sephiroth

Recommended Posts

I remember watching Dayne during a bowl game... first time I ever saw the guy, and my dad said, "that's the guy the Giants are probably going to draft."

 

My reply? "He looks fat and slow. Plus, who couldn't run with those holes that line is opening for him."

 

Yeah, I wanted Alexander instead, if we were going to go RB. Alexander put on a show in the SEC championship, against Florida.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't know man, taking Cedric Jones when Ray Lewis, Eddie George and Terry Glenn were still there is a head scratcher. Of course, no one knew what any of them would become.

 

Cedric Jones was so well adapted to being blind in one eye that he was able to compensate for it on the college level. The Giants were caught flat footed when they found out...AFTER...they drafted him.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

that's how they found out he was legally blind in one eye....

 

no they knew he was blind in one eye the whole time, training camp is when they found out about the new eye injury he got a month before the draft.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I remember watching Dayne during a bowl game... first time I ever saw the guy, and my dad said, "that's the guy the Giants are probably going to draft."

 

My reply? "He looks fat and slow. Plus, who couldn't run with those holes that line is opening for him."

 

Dude, I knew he was going to suck too.... He always put up great number against bad competition. But when played against good teams... he choked.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1989 was a particularly good draft (we're talking 3-4 guys who were starters the following year for a super bowl team):

 

C Brian Williams

G Bob Kratch

DB Greg Jackson

RB Dave Meggett

TE Howard Cross

DB Myron Guyton

 

Yeah, the oline was the biggest reason we won SB XXV. Young did a great job, starting in "88 with Moore and Elliott

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Spending a 1st round draft pick on Dave Brown has to rank down there as one of George Young's worst moves....and considering he sent Phil Simms packing to make room for Brown, it's even worse.

 

 

51550834-new-york-giants-quarterback-dave-brown-is-gettyimages.jpg?v=1&c=IWSAsset&k=2&d=DCGVs9kPkbaTpc80AhHvFK9T83IWTztj7830saLu2pWyQiJRu7gfnPmSWw6TgOpW

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Spending a 1st round draft pick on Dave Brown has to rank down there as one of George Young's worst moves....and considering he sent Phil Simms packing to make room for Brown, it's even worse.

 

 

51550834-new-york-giants-quarterback-dave-brown-is-gettyimages.jpg?v=1&c=IWSAsset&k=2&d=DCGVs9kPkbaTpc80AhHvFK9T83IWTztj7830saLu2pWyQiJRu7gfnPmSWw6TgOpW

 

Yeah, who spends a first round pick in the supplemental draft. I was 13, and went, ah fuck who gives up a first rounder for a Spurrier QB

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The failure rate of Big 10 RBs on this team is really rather remarkable, especially when you consider the fact that most of the guys on that list were high draft picks: 1st, 2nd or 3rd round picks... .it's not like these guys were late round development prospects, at the time.

 

Classic example of right idea, wrong personnel. Most of those picks happened when the Big Ten was all about offensive lines. What would have happened if we picked a guard from Wisconsin rather than Dayne, for instance?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Spending a 1st round draft pick on Dave Brown has to rank down there as one of George Young's worst moves....and considering he sent Phil Simms packing to make room for Brown, it's even worse.

 

 

51550834-new-york-giants-quarterback-dave-brown-is-gettyimages.jpg?v=1&c=IWSAsset&k=2&d=DCGVs9kPkbaTpc80AhHvFK9T83IWTztj7830saLu2pWyQiJRu7gfnPmSWw6TgOpW

 

Caused Reeves to hate Young all the more...because he had to be the one to ask for the playbook back from an unsuspecting Simms...while knowing what an utter steaming pile of shit Dave Brown was...Dan saw any chance of the playoffs fly right out the window for the next couple of years...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yeah, I hated Dave Brown as a kid too (imagine everyone else is rocking an Aikman, Young, Elway, Marino, etc jersey and you walk into school with Dave Brown on...fuck you) but it's not like the guy had any talent to work with. Horrible offensive line, no running backs, horrid receivers. Chris Calloway was his best wide out. Chris Callaway wouldn't even make the 2013 Giants roster.

 

I even gave my father shit. My 1st game I ever went to was in 1996 against the Patriots. Giants got out to a 22-3 lead and promptly lost 23 to 22. Dave Brown was QB. 16 years later, we take my brother to a game and the little fuck gets to watch Eli Manning throw for 510 yards in a 4th quarter comeback against the Bucs.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yeah, I hated Dave Brown as a kid too (imagine everyone else is rocking an Aikman, Young, Elway, Marino, etc jersey and you walk into school with Dave Brown on...fuck you) but it's not like the guy had any talent to work with. Horrible offensive line, no running backs, horrid receivers. Chris Calloway was his best wide out. Chris Callaway wouldn't even make the 2013 Giants roster.

 

I even gave my father shit. My 1st game I ever went to was in 1996 against the Patriots. Giants got out to a 22-3 lead and promptly lost 23 to 22. Dave Brown was QB. 16 years later, we take my brother to a game and the little fuck gets to watch Eli Manning throw for 510 yards in a 4th quarter comeback against the Bucs.

False.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yeah, I hated Dave Brown as a kid too (imagine everyone else is rocking an Aikman, Young, Elway, Marino, etc jersey and you walk into school with Dave Brown on...fuck you) but it's not like the guy had any talent to work with. Horrible offensive line, no running backs, horrid receivers. Chris Calloway was his best wide out. Chris Callaway wouldn't even make the 2013 Giants roster.

 

I even gave my father shit. My 1st game I ever went to was in 1996 against the Patriots. Giants got out to a 22-3 lead and promptly lost 23 to 22. Dave Brown was QB. 16 years later, we take my brother to a game and the little fuck gets to watch Eli Manning throw for 510 yards in a 4th quarter comeback against the Bucs.

 

George Young will always be the remembered to me as the man who rebuilt and then dismantled a great Giants team.

 

People always talk about Parcells walking out on the Giants......well, George Young was the dude who was trying to hire Bo Schembechler away from Michigan the year both of Parcells parents died during his rookie year, when he went 3-12-1. We'll never know for sure, because the Giants front office is way to classy to admit it, but I'd bet the ranch that the only reason Parcells was not canned was because Wellington Mara vetoed the decision. Again, I have no proof of that, but I couldn't see Wellington firing a rookie coach who just lost both his parents. That sort of scumbag move was entirely in Young's toolbox though, and don't think for a second that Parcells ever forgot.

 

And before Parcells won his 2nd championship, George made it clear that Belichick and Coughlin weren't in his plans either. No fucking way did Parcells split without Belichick and Coughlin knowing the plan.

 

Between the 3 of them, 7 Lombardi Trophies, but none of them as smart as George Young, apparently......so imagine the shock when the Giants looked like dog shit on a summertime sidewalk after he annointed Ray Handjob to lead the team. Dumping Phil Simms for Dave Brown was the cherry on that crap sundae.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

George Young will always be the remembered to me as the man who rebuilt and then dismantled a great Giants team.

 

People always talk about Parcells walking out on the Giants......well, George Young was the dude who was trying to hire Bo Schembechler away from Michigan the year both of Parcells parents died during his rookie year, when he went 3-12-1. We'll never know for sure, because the Giants front office is way to classy to admit it, but I'd bet the ranch that the only reason Parcells was not canned was because Wellington Mara vetoed the decision. Again, I have no proof of that, but I couldn't see Wellington firing a rookie coach who just lost both his parents. That sort of scumbag move was entirely in Young's toolbox though, and don't think for a second that Parcells ever forgot.

 

And before Parcells won his 2nd championship, George made it clear that Belichick and Coughlin weren't in his plans either. No fucking way did Parcells split without Belichick and Coughlin knowing the plan.

 

Between the 3 of them, 7 Lombardi Trophies, but none of them as smart as George Young, apparently......so imagine the shock when the Giants looked like dog shit on a summertime sidewalk after he annointed Ray Handjob to lead the team. Dumping Phil Simms for Dave Brown was the cherry on that crap sundae.

Yeah if Dave Brown was really secretly a good QB, just not surrounded by talent on the gmen... someone tell me how his post giants NFL career went...

 

I used to love watching Dan Reeves trying to explain away another Dave Brown Production with that hang dog face and Georgia Drawl...Reeves looked like he caught his preacher watching shit porn... :Smiley_StirringShit: :puke:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...