For the record, I'm not saying we should outright replace Eli. I'm saying he should be put on notice. The guy is a two-time Super Bowl MVP and deserves a shitty season, or even two, before he's out... and Gilly should definitely go before Eli does.
Now, that being said, Kerry Collins was a pretty darn good quarterback when he was in New York, and that didn't stop us from taking our franchise guy to lead the team for the next ten years. If and when we're statistically out of the playoffs, it'll be time to see if Ryan Nassib has what it takes to compete at the NFL level. If not, then getting a new QB should at least be on the table... we can't get by with another year of play like this out of a guy making 22 million, and it's time to start looking at "plan B" for if Eli doesn't recover from this.