Personally, I don't need a player's poll to tell me who's overrated or not. Eli is not Peyton... he's not Brees.. we can all agree to that. But to say he sucks is going to the other extreme. In a lot of ways you proved a point I'd raised earlier in that in football especially it's near imnpossible to compare players at the same position because of all the moving parts. Archie Manning they say was a great QB whose OL sucked major balls.. maybe his entire team did. In that sense, I think Eli is the best QB we've had in over 2 decades)
As far as Jacobs, I've at least in my own mind thrown in the towel.